Archive for the ‘Wrongful Death’ Category

Utah Drunk Driver Hits and Kills Motorcyclist

Tuesday, August 11th, 2009

A suspected drunk driver hit and killed a California man after hitting his motorcycle on Saturday, August 8th, 2009. The Salt Lake Tribune reports that 53 year-old, Leland Lloyd, was riding south on Greensprings Drive in Washington City, Utah. At around 9:15 a.m., a green Ford Explorer that was traveling northbound made a left-hand turn in front of Lloyd. Lloyd’s motorcycle and the Explorer collided head-on. Lloyd was killed instantly in this Utah motorcycle accident, when his forehead hit the Explorer. Police say he was wearing a helmet but his head made contact on a portion that was not protected.

Police have since arrested the 54-year-old driver of the Explorer, John Hanson of St. George, Utah. He was booked on suspicion of automobile homicide, driving under the influence of alcohol, driving with an open container and making an improper left turn.

This is a tragic Utah motorcycle crash. There is absolutely no excuse for drunk driving. My thoughts and prayers are with Leland Lloyd’s family as they cope with their loss.

For years I have held drunk drivers responsible for their irresponsible actions. If they make the choice to drive on our roads they should be prepared for the consequences. I advise the Lloyd family to contact an experienced personal injury attorney who can file a wrongful death claim against John Hanson’s insurance as well as make sure Hanson is held responsible for his actions.

Car Accident Near Wellington, Utah, Takes Provo Woman’s Life

Tuesday, July 28th, 2009

Authorities blame driving drowsy for a rollover on State Road 6 that claimed the life of a Provo Woman. The Utah car accident occurred on Saturday July 25, 2009. According to the Utah Highway Patrol and KSL news, the driver of a Nissan was headed west near Wellington just after 12:30 a.m. He started to fall asleep, drifted into oncoming traffic and swerved off the road into an embankment. The passenger in the backseat, 24-year-old Deanne Jones was killed instantly.

The driver was taken to Castleview Hospital with minor injuries.

I offer my condolences to the Jones family as they mourn this loss.

One dead; 7 Injured in a Utah Car Accident

Wednesday, July 15th, 2009

A van rollover on southbound I-15 on July 8, 2009, has left John Vibas dead and seven others injured. The crash took place in Millard County, Utah, reports the Salt Lake Tribune.

The Chevrolet Van was near Scipio when it went off the left shoulder early in the morning. The driver pulled the van pulled the van back to the right but went off the left shoulder again. The driver attempted to straighten out and steer back to the road but the vehicle rolled from the over-correction.

A total of 8 people were in the van. John Vibas of Alberta was ejected from the van and passed away at the scene. Two other passengers were rushed to Central Valley Medical Center with critical injuries, one was taken to the hospital in serious condition and four others were taken to the hospital as a precautionary measure.

The cause of the crash is still under investigation. I wish the surviving family and friends of John Vibas my sincere condolences.

I would also point out that the estate of John Vibas has a claim against the driver of the van or his insurance company for what sounds like negligent driving. I would advise them to speak with a Utah injury and accident lawyer to find out what remedies are available to them.

Fatal Provo Fire Raises Questions About Smoke Alarms

Thursday, March 5th, 2009

A 38-year-old man is dead following a fire in Provo, Utah on March 4, 2009. According to KSL News, the fire started at an older apartment complex located at 511 N. 100 West. Around 12:30 p.m., a resident from the complex called 911 to report that it appeared that smoke was coming from a light fixture. Fire crews showed up and determined that the fire was on the third floor. They forced their way into the apartment where they discovered a small fire, lots of smoke, and a dead man. Although the fire was said to be slow-moving, the cause of death was determined to be smoke inhalation. Fire investigators determined that it was a hot object placed in a laundry basket that started the fire. The cause of the fire has been ruled unintentional. Residents near the fire were evacuated while the fire crews put out the fire. They returned a short time later. According to reports, the person who placed the 911 call was not allowed back.
Investigators also determined that the smoke alarms were not functioning as they were intended. Both the alarm downstairs and the one in the deceased person’s apartment were not working. By reports, the smoke alarm upstairs actually had no battery in it. This raises the question of whether the apartment complex had procedures in place to make sure that its residents were safe if and when a fire broke out. What procedures did they have to make sure that every unit had at least one functioning smoke alarm at any given time? In new construction, every living area is required to have a working smoke alarm. Under this standard, it would seem that a one bedroom apartment should have at least two. I wonder how many other smoke alarms in the complex are not working and when the last time was that apartment inspected these smoke alarms. There obviously is a problem here that needs to be corrected. Ultimately, the apartment complex is responsible for the safety of their tenants and could be held responsible if they failed in this duty.
My condolences to the family of this man.

Infant on Mom’s Lap Perishes in Fatal Accident Near Payson

Monday, March 2nd, 2009

An infant is dead following a single-car rollover near Payson, Utah on March 1, 2009. According to the Salt Lake Tribune, a family was traveling from Las Vegas to Salt Lake City, Utah. Around Payson, the driver, Doris Licona, fell asleep at the wheel and lost control of the SUV she was driving. The vehicle bounced into a guard rail, she overcorrected, and the SUV ended up rolling at least twice in the median. Only one person of the five in the car was reported to have been wearing a seatbelt. This includes the mother of a young child, Michelle Nuila, 19 years of age, who had her 9-month old son Jonathan on her lap and was sitting in the front seat.
All front seat passengers, including the infant, were ejected out of the car. The baby died at the scene. The two in the back seat, a ten-year old and 2-year old, who were children of the driver, were taken to the hospital in stable condition. The two year old was the only person in the car that was restrained.
This is a simply tragic case that could have largely been avoided if the passengers had seat belts on. This includes the children who should be placed in age-appropriate car seats. A small child, who doesn’t know any better, should never ride in anyone’s lap. I suppose adults have their agency to choose for themselves. But parent’s must ensure that their minor children are always properly restrained.
Finally, driving while fatigued can be just as bad as driving drunk. It impairs drivers to the point that they are unable to safely operate their car.

Fatal West Jordan Fire Blamed on Machine Malfunction

Monday, February 23rd, 2009

A fire that took the life of 63-year-old John Williams is being blamed on a machine that caught fire. According to KSL News, a machine that Williams used as an assistant machine operator for Adroit Screw Machine Products Warehouse, overheated and caused 50 gallons of lubricant to catch fire, according to investigators with the West Jordan Fire Department. Assistant Chief Marc Mcelreath stated: “As that oil heated up it became flammable, and that was the reason the fire grew as fast as it did.”
On the day of the fire, February 20, 2009, Williams was trapped in the building when other workers had been able to get out. Williams had been with the company for 14 years and had formerly worked for the Rio Grand Railroad.
My condolences to the family for this tragic loss. Normally when an employee is injured or killed when in the line of duty, the family has a claim against the employee’s workers compensation carrier. In Utah, neither employees or their families can sue their employer. In this case, however, there very well likely could be a claim against the manufacturer of the machine that caught fire. Obviously, these machines are not supposed to do this. This raises the possibility that there was a defect in the machine that caused the lubricant to get as hot as it did, catching fire. There could also be a problem with the manufacturer failing to warn the company of the possibility that this kind of thing can happen. These kind of cases are called “product liability” cases.

Box Elder County Car Accident Claims Life of Young Man

Tuesday, February 17th, 2009

A 22-year-old man from Layton, Utah died from injuries received in a fatal car accident occurring on February 14, 2009. According to KSL News, the man, Joshua Discuillo of Layton, was originally rear-ended around 12:15 p.m. on Valentines day by a red pickup truck driven by a 31-year-old male while driving on the I-15 near mile marker 353. Both Discuillo and the other driver had pulled off the road and were outside their cars discussing the crash when a third vehicle, a silver car driven by a 37-year-old Bountiful, Utah woman lost control and slid into the two males. The other escaped serious injury, but Discuillo, unfortunately, was reportedly pinned between his car, a white Chevrolet Prism and the silver car. He was taken by ambulance as opposed to a helicopter because of heavy snow. The UHP has reported that the driver of the red pickup will received a citation for following too close the driver of the silver car will also be cited.

There is a principle in tort law that the person who causes the underlying incident to occur is responsible for all further injury stemming from the original incident. In this case, Joshua Discuillo was first rear-ended. It would seem that this was directly attributable to the driver of the red pickup. Because of that first crash, Discuillo was on the side of the road, in a snow storm, when he should have been miles down the highway. Because he was on the side of the road, in an area that apparently had very slippery roads, he was exposed to the negligent driving of another motorist.

This is a sad situation for all involved. Certainly no one intended to inflict injury or get hurt in this tragic car wreck. But injury and death did occur and it is likely that Utah’s legal system will have to sort this out. My condolences to all involved, especially the family of this young man who had his whole life ahead of him.

Published by: Ron Kramer

Update on Bicyclist Hit By Car in Fatal Salt Lake Bike Accident

Friday, February 13th, 2009

We earlier reported on a story where a 62-year old bicyclist, Leroy Martinez, was hit by a Mazda this past Monday, February 9, 2009 while crossing the street at a crosswalk at Navajo Street and Indiana Avenue in Salt Lake City, Utah. The police had reported that the cyclist had turned around in the crosswalk unexpectedly and that the motorist was unable to stop in time. Now, according to the Salt Lake Tribune, police are saying the bicyclist didn’t turn around at all before he was struck, that he was hit by the car just as he entered the crosswalk. The impact caused Martinez to suffer a fractured skull and internal bleeding in his brain. The police are now considering charges against the driver. This detail, of course, changes everything.

As I discussed, motorists are not allowed to run over pedestrians and cyclists that are in crosswalks. With this detail, it sounds like the motorist is to blame for hitting this man as he was trying to cross the street. What’s more, it appears that he may have initially given a false story to officers investigating this since the driver was claiming that Martinez had turned around in the crosswalk.

In Utah, those entitled to make claims for a “wrongful death” include the victim’s parents, children and spouse. Usually claims are made against the insurance company of the at-fault party. In this situation, there is also some modest funeral, death coverage that the driver’s “no-fault” insurance will provide in this situation.

Published by: Ron Kramer

Truck Accidents Near Beaver, Utah, Cause Injuries, Fatality–Update

Thursday, February 12th, 2009

Officials today, February 12, 2009, shut down the I-15 just south of Beaver, Utah, between mile markers 95 and 109, for a couple hours following a string of big truck-car accidents and the fatality of an 18 month-old infant.

According to a story in the Deseret News, the accidents first happened around 2:30 p.m. Around this time, witnesses say that the snow was coming down hard, yet it was bright outside. Witnesses report that it was a semi-truck and a passenger car that first collided, with the semi reportedly rear-ending the car in front of it. While they were trying to move the vehicles off the freeway, an 18-wheeler came along and hit the first semi, causing it to jacknife. Several cars that were by this truck, became involved in the crash. It is reported that other cars and trucks driving along this corridor also collided into each other.

Another tractor trailer truck carrying 1,000 gallons of fuel was also involved in a crash in this stretch of highway when it too hit another big rig in front of it. Several hundred gallons of fuel spilled onto the highway and areas surrounding the highway. The Utah Highway Patrol reports that 22 vehicles, including six semi trucks and one gas tanker, were involved in wrecks along this stretch of highway.

Seven people were taken to local hospitals. The infant child, who is now identified as Isaiah Rowley, of Orem, Utah, was taken to Valley View Medical Center in Cedar City where he passed away from injuries he received. By reports, the car the infant was in was rear ended by a semi-truck, which in turn caused the child’s car seat to push up into the front part of the vehicle. I offer my condolences to the family for the tragic loss of their child and best wishes to the others who were injured for a speedy recovery.

For the very reason that big rig trucks can inflict terrible injury and death on those they share the road with, the Dept. Of Transportation has issued a strict set of rules that truck drivers are required to follow. One of these rules, found in section 392.14, states:

“Extreme caution in the operation of a commercial motor vehicle shall be exercised when hazardous conditions, such as those caused by snow, ice, sleet, fog, mist, rain, dust, or smoke, adversely affect visibility or traction. Speed shall be reduced when such conditions exist. If conditions become sufficiently dangerous, the operation of the commercial motor vehicle shall be discontinued and shall not be resumed until the commercial motor vehicle can be safely operated. Whenever compliance with the foregoing provisions of this rule increases hazard to passengers, the commercial motor vehicle may be operated to the nearest point at which the safety of passengers is assured.”

The bottom line is that semi truck drivers have a higher duty to driver safely. Based on witness reports of heavy snow and ice on the highway, however, it doesn’t sound like the drivers of the big trucks involved in this crash fulfilled their duty under federal law.

After accidents involving semi trucks happen, the trucking companies, working with risk management companies that they belong to, will quite literally dispatch investigators to the scene to inspect the scene of the crash as well as the truck and document every conceivable aspect of the truck accident. They will review the driver’s log book, fuel receipts, dispatch reports, gps information, bills of lading, along with “black box” information. They will also physically inspect the cab of the truck to look to see if there are duplicate log books, that some less-than-honest truckers carry with them to see if the truck driver is honest in reporting his or her time behind the wheel. Fatigue and overworking have been shown to be big contributing factors to big rig crashes. All the information that the investigative team collects will then be analyzed by these risk managers and will be discussed by defense attorneys the organization keeps on retainer for situations like this. And all this will most likely happen in the first 24-36 hours, before the trucking victim or their family is even thinking about hiring an attorney.

It therefore goes without saying that those involved in this string of trucking crashes should consult with a personal injury attorney to find out what remedies they have available.

Published by: Ron Kramer

Bountiful Woman Perishes in Centerville Head-On Car Accident

Sunday, February 8th, 2009

A two vehicle collision in Centerville, Utah, on February 7, 2009, has taken the life of a 19-year-old West Bountiful teenager. According to KSL News, Kristy L. Bateman was driving a 1999 Suzuki Esteem north on Main St., just south of Lund Lane around 6:30 at night when the driver of a Pontiac Vibe driven by Jamie Beecher, 32, suddenly swerved into Bateman’s lane of travel, resulting in a head-on crash. Bateman was removed from her car using extraction equipment and flown to Intermountain Medical Center. Life-saving surgery was performed on her, but sadly, doctors were unable to save her, and she passed away late in the evening. Two other passengers in her car were treated for non-life-threatening injuries. Ms. Beecher and her two young children were also treated at the hospital. All drivers and passengers were reported to have been wearing seatbelts.

Video Courtesy of KSL.com

As I wrote a couple days ago, many fatal car accidents in Utah are caused by drivers who fail to follow the rules of the road and allow their vehicles to drift into the opposing lane of travel. Head-on collisions are a common cause of fatal car accidents in Sardine Canyon, near Logan, Utah and on Highway 6, near Helper, Utah. Based on witness accounts and physical evidence that the other driver swerved suddenly, I wonder if the at-fault driver wasn’t distracted by something in her car? There is also a possibility that her vehicle’s suspension failed at the precise moment she approached Kristy Bateman’s vehicle. We are told that the investigation is continuing as to how exactly this crash happened. My condolences to the family.

Published by: Ron Kramer